Never mind the quality, just keep taking the tablet

Print Friendly
Share Button

I have just taken part in a live Turnitin webcast, Grade Anywhere: Turnitin for iPad (free but you need to register your email address; you’ll then be sent a link to the webcast).

The webcast is meant to promote their new iPad app, and it seems it is true, now you can grade (almost?) anywhere. You don’t even need a live internet connection, as long as you synced your iPad to your Turnitin account and downloaded student work before you went offline.

turnitin for ipadA pity then that Turnitin itself is flawed.

During the webcast, we are presented with a student essay on an event which took place in 1980*, and shown how easy it is to annotate, strikethrough text, make comments, and more.

The narrator showed us how to add a bubble comment, “Nice photo,” to the photo in the essay.  And, as it’s Turnitin, we also get an Originality Check.

“Nice photo”?  Surely the student submitting this less-than-original essay had not been around to take the photograph himself? But there is no citation. “Nice photo” it might be, but it is not the student’s. Surely?

And the text? The Originality Check shows that the first paragraph is patchworked from three different sources. Not good.  About the only text not lifted from one of three sources is in the sentence “…mothers and friends of the United Sates players dashed onto …

A curious mis-spelling.

But hey, the Originality Check found no matches for the second paragraph.

A pity.  It’s been copied. It has been copied from an article in the New York Times Learning Network, U.S.A. Beats Soviet Union in ‘Miracle on Ice.’  In fact, the whole screen, maybe the whole essay (we are shown only these opening paragraphs so we cannot say), is copied from this ONE source. Including the typo, “United Sates.” The photo too.

Side by sideTechnology (or is it just Turnitin?).  Don’t stop thinking!

* This line was added 13 September 1980, to clarify the point being made. JRR
(The webcast was not publicly available at the time of posting; it is now. The link and parenthetical comment were added 13 September 2013.)

2 thoughts on “Never mind the quality, just keep taking the tablet

  1. Pingback: Imagine… (another flawed study) | Honesty, honestly…

  2. Pingback: Smoke and mirrors | Honesty, honestly…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *